Matt Maher is Not Saved, Stop Singing His Music in Church


Modern Evangelicals are happily embracing a deceptive evil, and letting it creep into their churches. The evil is a counterfeit gospel, a counterfeit Christianity. The evil is the Roman Catholic Church, and it’s creeping in unawares, especially to young and impressionable minds, through worship music. Particularly, a Catholic singer named Matt Maher has become strikingly popular in Evangelical worship. With the compromise of today’s Evangelical leadership, this should come as no surprise. Al Mohler once said he believed that there would be millions of Catholics in heaven. Other Southern Baptists are declaring confessing, professing Roman Catholics saved (See here, and here). And it just about every contemporary Baptist church, you’ll hear “worship” music written by Roman Catholics.

Charles Spurgeon once said,

I question if hell can find a more fitting instrument within its infernal lake than the Church of Rome is for the cause of mischief. And your church will in its measure, be the same if bereft of the Spirit.

What a gem of truth. The rate at which Evangelicals are embracing this false spirit as alarming. Historically, and as a result of the conservative resurgence, Southern Baptists have withstood much of the apostasy that has befallen other denominations. For the most part, Southern Baptists have held a strong (but weakening) stance against homosexuality entering the church. At least, for now, you don’t find acceptance of homosexuality preached from the pulpits in most SBC churches. And most SBC pastors aren’t going to recommend to their congregation books written by homosexual activists, like Matthew Vines, that call themselves Christians.

So why do we make exceptions for Roman Catholics? Why do we declare them saved when they reject the true Gospel? Why do we worship to music written by Matt Maher, a Roman Catholic?

Evangelicals are being duped. Roman Catholicism, like any other false religion, is an abomination to God. It is absolutely asinine for Al Mohler to believe that there would be millions of Catholics in heaven. Does Al Mohler believe there will be millions of Mormons in heaven too? How about millions of practicing homosexuals? Would he want devotionals written by Matthew Vines to be studied in Sunday School at his church? What about prayers written by Glenn Beck to be read during worship service? Do you see the inconsistency?

Yet, Evangelicals everywhere are embracing Roman Catholicism as brothers and sisters in Christ. Russell Moore recently said in an article he co-authored with Roman Catholic, Marco Rubio, “both of us are of the Christian faith.”

By the way, did you know Reformation Charlotte has a Christian gear and apparel store? Check it out at

Why do they believe this?

Roman Catholics cannot be Christians because they reject Jesus as wholly sufficient for the remission of their sins. Because of this, they practice idolatry regularly, through the mass, in which a priest supposedly summon Jesus out of Heaven to enter a wafer, and then proceed to eat and drink the physical body and blood of what they believe to be Jesus, present in the wafer. They practice idolatry through the veneration of Mary and the Saints in order to try to gain favor with God. They reject the fellowship of a true, local church that teaches and exposits the Scriptures authoritatively. And they practice idolatry by putting their faith in their man-made organization, hierarchical priest system, and sacraments for their salvation.

Or do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: neither the sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor men who practice homosexuality, nor thieves, nor the greedy, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God. And such were some of you. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God. – 1 Corinthians 6:9-11

Let me make that clear: Do not be deceived, a practicing, unrepentant Roman Catholic will not enter the Kingdom of Heaven. It doesn’t matter if a Roman Catholic “sounds evangelical” in his testimony. If he’s in the Roman Catholic Church and doesn’t see anything wrong with the idolatry he practices daily, he has not been justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God.

It doesn’t matter if Matt Maher says he’s a Christian or makes a “Christian-sounding” profession of faith. He is still a Roman Catholic, who practices idolatry, and is not repentant of it. It doesn’t matter if some of his music sounds okay. It doesn’t matter if he says he believes in Jesus. If he is unrepentant of his sin, he has not been regenerated.

But let’s go out on a limb here, and say that perhaps he is saved, and just hasn’t come to realize yet through sanctification that he’s caught up in a false religion. Sanctification is both immediate and progressive, therefore, it is possible for a Roman Catholic to be saved, and still (temporarily) be in the Roman Catholic Church. It still doesn’t matter. He’s still practicing sin, should be called to repentance, and by no means should he, or his worship music be played in a Bible-believing church. We wouldn’t do that for other unrepentant sinners. Why do we make exceptions for Roman Catholics?

We wouldn’t do that for other unrepentant sinners. Why do we make exceptions for Roman Catholics?


  1. You are exactly what is wrong in the name of RELIGION! Who are you to judge? The Catholic Church has been around for 2000 years and will be around for a lot more. When you point the finger, there are three pointing back at you. Matthew Maher is saved. He is more holy than you who wrote this article. Who are you to say this? What is wrong with other religions? It is a sign of weakness . God loves a universal church. When you preach this, it shows how weak your faith is. Grace , Mercy and love is the basis of the Catholic religion. I would suggest you try to Preach that. May God Bless you.

    • Amen…. Thank you for your response, Maria! After reading this article by Mr. Maples, I found his words and his hate speech alarming. Your response of peace and love is far more of a Christian attitude than this man’s disturbing words, arrogant attitude and negative accusations toward Catholics and Matt Maher. We are all Christians. Jeff Maples does not speak like a Christ filled person and is filled with nothing but judgement and hate. Jesus would never say such awful things. I love my Catholic Faith and so do millions of Christians in this world. Mr. Maples’ angry, ignorant words toward other Christians come across as judgemental, harsh, and scary. I feel sorry for him that his professed Christ-like heart is filled with so much hate, I think he might have missed Jesus’s message of peace, hope and love. He seems to be missing the true love, teaching and peace of Jesus Christ. He sounds like a bigoted, hateful person, not a Christian. Who is anyone to stand in judgment of how any Christian worships Jesus Christ? I wonder if Mr. Maples consulted God or His word before he chose to wrote this truly vicious and un-Christian article? Perhaps he might find some peace and answers by watching some footage of Matt Maher performing with fellow Christians such as Chris Tomlin and others who teach and share their love of Christ in fellowship with one another. Their love for Jesus and sharing their gift of music and worship TOGETHER, regardless of denomination, in their love of the same God and Savior, might help Mr. Maples’ judgemental soul to understand how universal God’s love and salvation is. There is no place in this world (or God’s) for this toxic attitude and narrow-minded brand of hate toward our fellow Christians. Please, Mr. Maples, do some reading and research to educate yourself before branding and condemning …. research the Catholic Faith, there is no form of idol worship or any of the other accusations you are writing of. Educate yourself on the Catholic doctrine, Faith and belief before you write with such uneducated vitrioI hate. I will pray for you, Jeff Maples. May peace be with you.

  2. I’m chuckling. It’s amazing protestants are ignorant of church history. I wonder if this person realizes there was only 1 church from the time of Jesus and the apostles to the reformation? And it was Catholic. I would not want to be these people on judgement day…

  3. Criticism of others is thus an oblique form of self-commendation. We think we make the picture hang straight on our wall by telling our neighbors that all his pictures are crooked.

  4. Mr Maples makes some valid point focus on them on not get emotional. Apparently most here haven’t read how Jesus condemned and chastised the religious leaders of his day the Pharisees and the Saudecees. He called them whitewashed tombs. Please read you Bibles and be enlightened by what God says and not the Pope the church or the Priests say.

Leave a reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Comment moderation is enabled. Your comment may take some time to appear.

Latest news

Amid Abortion, Black Pastor Says “We’ve Lost the Right to Be Outraged” Over KKK Lynchings

There is no humanitarian crisis in the world more horrific than the abortion holocaust taking place in...

Law and Order Easily Restored in Seattle’s CHAZ/CHOP “Autonomous Zone”

As we've watched the systemic escalation of immaturity and childish behavior take over one of Seattle's neighborhoods...

BLM Activist Assaults Black Man For Tearing Down BLM Signs, Threatens Kids

Black Lives Matter is clearly not about black lives. If it were, you wouldn't see stuff like...

Lecrae Responds to Chick-fil-A CEO’s Shoe-shining Stunt, Calls it Virtue Signaling

Last week, Reformation Charlotte reported on the virtue-signaling stunt that Chick-fil-A CEO, Dan Cathy, pulled during a...

Charismatic False Prophet, Todd White, Compares Holy Spirit to Pooping Dog

Todd White is the false teacher and faux faith-healer who is known for his parlor tricks such as leg-lengthening...

A Letter to a “Woke” Pastor: The Error of Political Correctness in the Pulpit

I took the time to listen carefully to your sermon of June 7, 2020; and I wanted to address what was preached that day. But before I start, I need to give you some facts about my life and ministry so you will have the context for why I am writing to you. Please excuse the length

Must read

- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you